CarneAtlas
← Sirloin

Sirloin substitutes

Sirloin is the traditional name in United States. Elsewhere, butchers sell the same piece — or a close cousin — under a different name.

Alternatives to sirloin steak

A US sirloin (top sirloin) is a lean, beefy steak at a moderate price, cut from the hip just behind the loin. The best alternatives are steaks from the same area or ones with a similar balance of flavour and price. Lean steaks like these are best cooked hot and fast to medium-rare and sliced across the grain.

Same area
Tri-tip, from the bottom sirloin. Grill it whole and slice it. Tri-tip guide →
Rump
The British and Australian cut that covers much of the same muscle. Rump steak is the direct swap outside the US. Rump steak →
More tender
New York strip. More marbling and a higher price; British butchers call it sirloin. New York strip →
Cheaper and tender
Flat iron, from the shoulder. Very tender for the price once the seam of gristle down the middle is removed. Flat iron →
Top sirloin cap
The fat-capped top of the sirloin, sold as picanha. Picanha →
What to ask for
Jump straight to your country.

Order one of these

Substitutes for Sirloin that can be delivered rather than hunted down at a counter.

Alcatra

🇧🇷 Brazil · Close substitute

Alcatra

Top sirloin steaks — the US cut closest to alcatra

Affiliate links — CarneAtlas may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

United States

Tri-tipapproximate

Both are from the sirloin primal with moderate tenderness and good flavour, but tri-tip is a distinct triangular muscle with a stronger flavour and better suited to roasting whole.

Brazil

Alcatraclose substitute

The same top-sirloin/rump region. Alcatra is the Brazilian–Portuguese name; sirloin (top sirloin) the US–UK one. Same primal, different tradition.

Picanhaapproximate

Picanha sits above the sirloin and shares similar flavor profile, but is kept with its fat cap and treated as a distinct roasting cut in Brazilian tradition.

France

Aiguillette baronneapproximate

Same primal — aiguillette baronne is a specific muscle within the broader top-sirloin region; sirloin is the broader cut.

Germany

Tafelspitzapproximate

Adjacent primal — the rump cap sits at the bottom edge of the sirloin/round area depending on the regional butchery system.

United Kingdom

Rump steakapproximate

Adjacent cuts from the hindquarter with similar flavor profiles — rump has slightly more chew and flavor while sirloin is marginally more tender.

← Full Sirloin details